California Declares State of Emergency Over Bird Flu: Lessons from COVID-19 Loom

California Governor Gavin Newsom has issued a State of Emergency citing a bird flu outbreak that has moved to dairy cattle as reason. The outbreak, which is now present in milk from infected cows, has prompted quarantines at 600 dairies, but no human-to-human transmission has been observed in California or elsewhere. Emergency efforts aim to contain the spread, ensure biosecurity, and protect public health, with officials emphasizing the low current risk to the public. Globally, H5N1 bird flu has infected over 860 people since 2003, with a 53% fatality rate, yet there have been no deaths in the United States during this outbreak.

Editor’s Note: California’s declaration of emergency has important ramifications. It enables stricter public health campaigns, tighter biosecurity regulations in affected dairies, and increased surveillance of any human diseases. A State of Emergency gives the government more authority and resources to utilize however they see fit, in contrast to a standard alert, which functions as a warning or advise.

However, it also increases public anxiety and raises questions about potential economic disruptions in the dairy and poultry industries. The heightened public fear surrounding the bird flu outbreak echoes the widespread anxiety seen during the COVID-19 pandemic. Many emergency measures that were initially considered necessary during that crisis—like lengthy lockdowns and inconsistent mask mandates—were later examined and shown to be ineffectual or unduly restrictive. This history raises concerns about whether the current emergency response to bird flu will follow a similar trajectory, with actions potentially driven more by fear than by clear evidence of effectiveness.

Read Original Article